Module 5: Proactive Processes

Problem Management

In this implementation guide we will take you through the appropriate steps to get your problem management process started successfully:

    Define the scope for implementation.

    Prepare to implement problem management.

    Problem management Implementation plan.

    Review your progress and define next steps.

    Define the scope for implementation

    The most important part of problem management is that underlying problems are identified and resolved. As with incident management, the tools you use to facilitate this are of secondary importance and when they are complex they can often get in the way of a successful process of implementation.

    Start small and learn the process
    The tool you use doesn't really matter, as long as you record the details of problems and their solutions. The information you record will help you build up a knowledge base of useful information, including known errors, which can be referred to when looking for solutions to incidents.

    Through reporting you will also build up a picture of the nature of the problems that are occurring and this will help you identify any common causes that can be targeted to further reduce the likelihood of incidents.

    Start by using our problem management templates for recording problems, tracking them and creating reports. They will provide you with a good introduction to the requirements of the process.

    Widen the scope when the process is familiar
    When you have been using the problem management process for long enough to understand it thoroughly and when your incident management process is ready also, you should consider implementing a suitable software tool to manage problems (and incidents) and automate reporting. If you choose a tool with a built-in knowledge base feature, you will be able to store known error information in a retrievable way, in addition to improving and speeding up your process, reporting and trend analysis capabilities.

    The schools which successfully implemented problem management are structured and methodical in their approach to this process. Network managers and technicians met on a regular basis with senior managers to analyse data, agree the issues and develop action plans to address them. These schools are also disciplined in their approach to problem-solving and apply a problem analysis tool (such as root cause analysis and fishbone diagrams).

    Independent 'Evaluation of the Framework for ICT Technical Support (FITS)'

    Establish your problem management goal
    The goal of problem management is to minimise both the number and severity of incidents and problems in your school. It should aim to reduce the adverse impact of incidents and problems that are caused by errors in the ICT infrastructure, and to prevent recurrence of incidents related to these errors.

    • You should address problems in priority order, paying attention to the resolution of problems that can cause serious disruption.
    • The degree of management and planning required is greater than that needed for incident control, where the objective is restoration of normal service as quickly as possible.
    • The function of problem management is to ensure that incident information is documented in such a way that it is readily available to all technical support staff.

    Problem management has reactive and proactive aspects:

    • reactive – problem solving when one or more incidents occur
    • proactive – identifying and solving problems and known errors before incidents occur in the first place.

    Problem management includes:

    • problem control, which includes advice on the best work-around available for that problem
    • error control.

    Prepare to implement problem management

    Good preparation can make the difference between success and failure.

    Roles and responsibilities

    The first step is to identify who will be involved in the process and assign roles and responsibilities to them. For the initial implementation you should involve as few people as possible so that the tasks can become familiar with minimum impact on the day-to-day workload. Assigning roles and responsibilities will depend on how you provide technical support currently and who is involved already.

    Training

    After you have assigned roles and responsibilities, it is important that those participating understand what is required of them. Use this reference material as the basis for your preparation for FITS accreditation.

    Start date

    Setting a start date for the process to 'go live' is important to focus those involved and to mark the changeover to new methods in the team and for your end-users. Make sure that you allow enough time to do all the other preparatory tasks beforehand.

    Communication

    Communication must take place within the implementation team to agree plans, schedule dates and so on, but it is important also to communicate externally and inform the end-user community of the new process. The implementation of a process can be seen as a change, just like the upgrading of a server, and the impact on the user community should be communicated to them clearly in advance of the change.

    Materials

    Before you can go ahead with the implementation, you will need all the materials required for the process. Make sure that you have downloaded the templates you need and that everyone involved has access to them.

    Pilot

    A good way to test problem management is to record and log one problem and manage its progress through to resolution. Review the test problem and discuss any issues. When you are happy that everyone understands the requirements and that all roles are fulfilled adequately, you can 'go live' with the process, but you should feel free to complete as many tests as necessary beforehand. You should have implemented FITS incident management before FITS problem management and if you have done so you will find that the processes are very similar.

    The main difference between these processes is that problem management does not have the urgency and frequent end-user communication characteristics of incident management. Provided that you fully understand the concept of incidents and problems and are comfortable with the difference between the processes, you may feel a pilot for problem management is unnecessary.

    Prerequisites

    Because problems are often identified during the course of incident resolution you should implement FITS incident management before FITS problem management. This is also true because incidents must be dealt with before problems, to provide good customer service.

    Having a service desk will help you manage problems more effectively but if you have implemented incident management you should have dealt with this at the same time anyway.

    FITS Change Management is also a prerequisite process, because by definition a problem will result in a change. You can implement a problem solution without the change management process but you could significantly increase the risk of introducing new problems if you do.

    Problems are also identified as a result of network monitoring and preventative maintenance, so to gain the full benefit of problem management you will need to implement the FITS Availability and Capacity Management process. It is not a prerequisite though, and can be added at any time. You might find it helpful to build your problem management slowly, by dealing with only those problems that result from incidents to begin with, and adding other proactive input from network monitoring and preventative maintenance gradually.

    The problem management implementation plan

    This section tells you how to implement a basic problem management process using downloadable templates. You can use the templates as they are or personalise them. The templates are referred to as required throughout the implementation guide and are also collected together in the Toolkit.

    The steps required to manage problems are:

    • Step 1: Identify problem
    • Step 2: Record details of problem
    • Step 3: Enter details in problem log
    • Step 4: Investigate and diagnose problem
    • Step 5: Raise request for change
    • Step 6: Resolve and close problem
    • Step 7: Update problem log

    Step 1: Identify the problem

    A problem may be identified in one of the following ways:

    • As a result of incident management – an incident may have an underlying cause that requires repair
    • As a result of network monitoring – monitoring activities may identify failed or faulty equipment
    • As a result of preventative maintenance – maintenance activities may identify failed or faulty equipment

    In every case they will be identified by someone technical involved in the above processes who will record details of the problem.

    Step 2: Record details of the problem

    Using the problem record template, the person logging the problem creates a problem record for each new problem, filling in the first part of the form ('Part 1 – problem details'). The table below guides you through each field.

    Field

    Guidance

    Problem number

    The problem number is a unique reference for the purpose of identifying the problem record. This number should be obtained from the problem manager who will take the next available sequential number from the problem log.

    Problem logged by

    Enter the name of the person recording the details (the problem logger).

    Related incident number

    Enter the number of the incident to which the problem relates. This can be found on the incident record. If the problem does not relate to an incident, enter 'N/A' to show that the field has been considered.

    Name of owner

    Enter the name of the owner of the affected item. This may be an end-user if the problem relates to an end-user incident. In cases where a problem relates to shared ICT infrastructure equipment, the owner can be the ICT department or technical support.

    Location

    Enter the location of the affected equipment.

    Contact number

    Enter a contact number if possible, such as when the problem relates to end-user equipment. Enter 'N/A' if no number can be given, to show that the field has been considered.

    Equipment's unique ID

    If the equipment relating to the problem has been assigned a unique ID, enter it here.

    Date and time problem logged

    Enter the date and time that the problem is recorded.

    Details of problem/action required following incident resolution

    Enter details of the next actions required. If the problem does not relate to an incident record, include full details of what has been done to date. If the problem does relate to an incident, make reference to the details in the incident record or add any other useful information not recorded there.

    Work around to be removed?

    Circle 'yes' or 'no'. If 'yes', enter details of the work-around to remove.

    Loan equipment to be removed?

    Circle 'yes' or 'no'. If 'yes', enter full details of all loan equipment to remove, including unique ID number(s) and the location the equipment is to be returned to.

    Problem assigned to

    Enter the name of the person who will be the problem resolver. This may be the same person as the problem logger or it may be another, more appropriate member of the technical team. If guidance is required, the problem management process owner should have final responsibility, although they may delegate this responsibility to the problem manager if appropriate.

    When the details have been recorded, the problem logger gives the problem record to the problem manager, who will enter the details in the problem log.

    Step 3: Enter details in the problem log

    Using the problem record template, the problem manager creates a problem log and records summary details of the problem for tracking purposes. Each new problem is added to the next line of the problem log. The table below guides you through each field.

    Field

    Guidance

    Problem number

    The problem number on the log should correspond to the problem number on the problem record. Use the problem log to generate the next sequential number.

    Date problem logged

    Enter the date the problem was logged from the problem record. For convenience and consistency the template column is formatted DD-MMM-YY.

    Time problem logged

    Enter the time the problem was logged from the problem record. For convenience and consistency the template column is formatted HH:MM (24 hours).

    Equipment unique ID

    Enter the equipment unique ID (if available) from the problem record. Enter 'n/a' if not available.

    Related incident number

    Enter the related incident reference number. If the problem does not relate to an incident, enter 'n/a'.

    Name of owner

    Enter the name of the owner of the affected equipment from the problem record.

    Summary of problem

    Summarise the information in the 'Details of problem' field on the problem record. It is not necessary to transfer the details in full - just a reminder of the nature of the problem is sufficient.

    Problem logged by

    Enter the name of the problem logger.

    Problem assigned to

    Enter the name of the problem resolver.+

    Step 4: Investigate and diagnose the problem

    It may be that the root cause of the problem has already been identified as a result of an incident investigation, in which case details should have been provided on the problem record. If not, the problem resolver is responsible for investigating and diagnosing the problem. It may be necessary to review full details of an incident in either case. Full details will be found in the corresponding incident record.

    When a problem has been diagnosed, the problem resolver should complete the following fields on the problem record and report the information recorded to the problem manager for tracking purposes. If the problem resolver does not provide this information they can expect the problem manager to contact them and request an update.

    Field

    Guidance

    Diagnosis/next Actions

    Enter details of the diagnosis and next actions to be taken.

    The problem manager should update the problem log as follows, and proactively seek this information if it is not forthcoming.

    Field

    Guidance

    Diagnosis/next Actions

    Enter a summary of the next actions, from the problem record.

    After diagnosis, the problem logger will raise a request for change to implement the solution.

    Step 5: Raise a request sheet

    In order to resolve a problem it will be necessary to make a change to the affected equipment.

    Example changes include: the replacement of a faulty hard drive, the installation of an operating system patch, the installation of additional memory and so on. Such changes should be planned and executed in accordance with FITS Change Management, by creating and approving a request for change form.

    If you implement your change without using a suitable change management process, you run the risk of introducing new problems.

    When the request for change form has been created, the problem resolver should complete the following fields on the problem record and report the information recorded to the problem manager for tracking purposes.

    Field

    Guidance

    Related request for change number

    Enter the number of the request for change form created in preparation of the problem resolution.

    The problem manager should update the problem log as follows.

    Field

    Guidance

    Related request for change number

    Enter the request for change number

    When preparations are complete, the problem resolver will resolve and close the problem.

    Step 6: Resolve and close problem

    The solution can be implemented when it has been approved through the change management process. Any work-arounds should be removed and loan equipment returned, as indicated in the problem record.

    When a problem has been resolved, the problem resolver should complete the following fields on the problem record and pass the information recorded to the problem manager for tracking purposes. If the problem resolver does not provide this information they can expect the problem manager to contact them and request an update.

    Field

    Guidance

    How was the problem resolved?

    Describe the solution. The purpose of recording this information is for future reference, to understand what was done and to provide potential solutions for other problems. It is insufficient to enter 'job done'.

    Work-around removed

    Circle 'yes' or 'not applicable'.

    Loan equipment removed and returned

    Circle 'yes' or 'not applicable'.

    Date problem closed

    Enter the date the problem was closed.

    Problem closed by

    Enter the name of the person who closed the problem.

    When it has been completed, the problem resolver passes the problem record to the problem manager so that they can update the problem log and file the problem record in the configuration management database.

    Step 7: Update the problem log

    On receipt of the completed problem record, the problem manager should update the problem log as follows. The problem manager should monitor the problem log and proactively seek the completed paperwork if it is not forthcoming.

    Field

    Guidance

    Summary of solution

    Summarise the description of the solution from the problem record.

    Date problem closed

    Enter the date the problem was closed from the problem record.

    Problem closed by

    Enter the name of the person who closed the problem from the problem record.

    The problem manager files the finished problem record in the configuration management database. (This can be a folder for paper records.)

    Review your progress and define next steps

    Review your first problem record and log entry and check them thoroughly. Deal with any shortcomings promptly – review each problem record and log entry following completion until you are satisfied that the process is working. Ask yourself:

    • Did everyone understand what was required of them?
    • Were problem record forms available to problem loggers?
    • Were problem record forms completed fully?
    • Was the information recorded by problem loggers and problem resolvers meaningful and unambiguous?
    • Was the problem log updated with each new problem?
    • Was the problem log updated with progress at the relevant stages of each problem?
    • Were update information and completed problem records returned promptly by problem resolvers?
    • Does training need to be revisited before continuing?

    Problem Management Reports

    The measurements you have gathered are similar to those for incident management and, like incident management, they are the starting point for helping you to understand what is happening in problem management in your school. They do not provide any answers, only the questions you must ask.

    Look carefully at the statistics and then find out their causes. Identify trends and ask questions, look back through problem records, talk to problem management staff. Dig around for the root cause. It is important to identify and resolve issues with the process to ensure that it continues to operate effectively.

    Measurement

    Purpose

    Example questions

    Number of problems logged

    To monitor whether volume is increasing or decreasing over time and understand the cause.

    • Has anything specific happened to cause an increase or decrease?
    • Is the change management process working effectively?
    • Have school holidays affected volumes?
    • Has a problem record been completed for every problem?
    • Was a problem record completed for every problem in the last period?
    • Could a decrease indicate waning enthusiasm for the process?
    • Could an isncrease indicate a surge of enthusiasm for the process?

    Number of problems closed

    To monitor the performance of problem management staff.

    • Has the number of problems closed gone up or down since the last report?
    • Were more or fewer problems logged in the last period?
    • Were problems more, or less, complex to resolve than those in the last period?
    • Were staff levels similar from one period to the next?
    • Was workload affected by other factors?
    • Were problem management staff diverted to working on incidents?

    Number of problems fixed within 1 week

    To monitor performance against internal targets. With effective incident management, problem resolution within 1 month should be adequate and achievable.

    • How does this compare with previous months?
    • What was the complexity of the problems?
    • Were staff levels consistent?
    • Was workload affected by other factors?

    Number of problems fixed in more than 1 month

    To monitor performance against internal targets. Even though effective incident management should be providing acceptable customer service, you may find that failure to resolve underlying problems in 1 month or less will stretch your resources and increase risks to service provision.

    • Were staff levels consistent?
    • Were there supplier delays?
    • Was resolution held up by the change management process?
    • Are outstanding problems scheduled but waiting for new releases (for example, a software patch)?
    • Was workload affected by other factors?
    • Were problem management staff diverted to working on incidents?
    • Do you have enough spares left to deal with future incidents?

    Problem management reports should identify where isolating problems from incidents has provided benefit.

    Customer satisfaction analysis and surveys

    Satisfaction surveys are an excellent method of monitoring customer perception and expectation and can be used as a powerful marketing tool.

    However, to ensure success you should address several key points:

    • Decide on the scope of the survey
    • Decide on the target audience
    • Clearly define the questions
    • Make the survey easy to complete
    • Conduct the survey regularly
    • Make sure that your customer understands the benefits
    • Publish the results
    • Follow through on survey results
    • Translate survey results into actions.

    Also bear in mind the following points on measurements:

    • Do not set targets that cannot be measured
    • Ensure that customers are aware of what you are doing, and why
    • Establish a baseline before discussing formal service-level agreements (SLAs) with customers. (See FITS Service Level Management)
    • Maintain measurements of what is necessary and viable. For instance, if your staff think that they need feedback on response times, then measure them!

    Members Only Content - Please LOGIN OR purchase below

    FITS Member

    This content is for members only.  Please purchase below to get instant access.

    Special Limited Time Offer

    Get full member access for only £4.95/m

     We are currently offering full access to the members area for a very special rate.

    Some content on this website is provided under the provisions of the Open Government License. 
    All other content including, but not restricted to, website design, images logos, etc. 

    Copyright © 2020 - FITSEd. All Rights Reserved

    Page Created with OptimizePress